India’s paradox: As the nation develops, more farmers commit suicide
57 Star
Share This Post
Subhash , Kolkata: Feb 13 2008
Made Popular Feb 13 2008

indian_farmer_suicides Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Finance Minister P Chidambaram and Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar have proudly said on number of occasions that India is all set to achieve double-digit growth in coming days. You can ask why I am putting Sharad Pawar’s name in the series of PM and FM here in the report.

The reason behind is the poor growth of agriculture in the country and despite the poor show Agriculture minister himself is rallying with other two colleagues. I am research scholar doing Doctorate of Philosophy (Ph.D.) on topic – “Is India really developing without Agriculture”. I am very much thankful to my guide for assigning me this topic that gave me the chance to know the real picture of Indian agriculture.

During my visit to Maharashtra to know basic cause of thousands of farmers’ suicide, I was stunned to see apathetic conditions of farmers’ families in several villages in the region. I would blame media for hardly putting their plight in their perspective. The children of farmers had committed suicide because of inabilities of their parents to fight with poverty and debts. Some of the farmers had even protested with slogans in their hands - “Every farmer counts. Every child dreams.”

Indian government and state governments have no time even to think about these poor farmers and they are busy counting the shopping malls in cities to show the growth and setting up Special Economic Zones on land acquired forcefully from poor farmers.

When I heard a painful story of 16-year-old Dharmendra in a village how his father consumed pesticide and his mother burnt herself to death rather facing the ignominy of having the artiya (moneylender) on her doorstep every week. My heart bled when Dharmendra, who still owes Rs4 to 5 hundred thousand to the local moneylender, was telling his story with tears in his eyes.

It was just one example and you can find countless number of such examples in almost every village in Vidarbha region. One suicide in every eight hours – official data tells the real story. It is refreshing departure from the statements made by senior ministers in the Union Cabinet.

In India, more than 80 crore people are still spending an average of Rs20 per day on livelihood. Rural India is crying for attention but no one in the government has time to listen. The growth rate in farming sector is just 3.8 per cent in last financial year. Agriculture is likely to grow at mere 2.6 per cent in 2007-08, and the industry and services sectors are projected to grow at 8.6 and 10.6 per cent, respectively. Isn’t it a real picture of agriculture in India?

Data says that 17,000 farmers committed suicide in the year 2006 and 4,500 committed suicide in Maharashtra alone. In the month of January 2008, 74 suicides have been reported in Vidarbha. For these farmers, to plough is no longer lucrative, migration to other cities is too costly, and they find only one way to get rid of moneylenders’ threat – SUICIDE.

According to the National Crime Records Bureau’s (NCRB) report entitled, ‘Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India, 2006’, 4,453 farmers, over a quarter of the all-India total of 17,060, committed suicide in 2006 in the state of Maharashtra. It was said to be the worst figure recorded in any year for any state since the NCRB first started recording farmers’ suicides in Indian states. The most shocking part of the story is that it happened in the same year when both the Prime Minister and chief minister had announced the relief packages worth 4,825 crores for farmers of Vidarbha.

Let me give you the most horrible data of the century collected from rural parts of India – more than 1,50,000 farmers committed suicide between the year 1997 and 2005 and two-thirds of the total count were from just four ‘developed’ states – ‘Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh’. An eminent journalist P Sainath, the 2007 winner of the Ramon Magsaysay Award for journalism, literature and creative communications arts has named these states as the ‘Suicide SEZ’ or ‘Special Elimination Zone’ for farmers.

One of the ‘prosperous’ states Punjab was once intended to be the paragon of the Green Revolution success story but now farmers in the state have committed suicide by jumping in front of trains, setting themselves on fire, or poisoning themselves. The nutrients of the land are being degraded because of the over-use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers to grow the genetically modified seeds successfully. Farmers do think that chemicals ensure a higher output but it only leads to further devastation of the land.

This is the real irony of India farmers that when the BSE SENSEX goes down, the Finance Minister and Prime Minister themselves promptly give assurance to investors by saying the government will take care of their financial interest in stock market. But when farmers commit suicide in large numbers due to indebtedness, forget the PM and FM, even the Agriculture Minister doesn’t bother to say a single line of assurance for the farmers’ families. This is real shame of new modern and developing India.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
1 Stars
Ruli
Columbus, United States
Interesting!!! And Indian government says country is developing with inclusive growth. This is an eye opener for those politicians - see your army of farmers is committing suicide.
1 Stars
Declining number of Big Cats down from 3,642 to 1,411 in six years is an international news. No one in the government is even thinking how and why 1,50,000 farmers committed suicide in eight years between the year 1997 and 2005. 17000 farmers committed suicide alone in 2006 and the government is serious about declining numbers of tiger population. This is the irony of India. God knows towards where we are heading from here.
1 Stars
Haris
islamabad, Pakistan
Indians hardly write or say something truth about their developmental saga. It is a real piece of writing revealing truth of Indian farming sector.
1 Stars
Ayushi
Calicut, India
No rain, No money, No life losing lands to SEZs- This is all about farmers in India.
1 Stars
Simon
London, United Kingdom
This is more than strange Indian government is ignoring its farmers as they are ending their lives at such large scale. What kinda development is this? Agriculture is the base of any country's economic prosperity. How would the government feed its one billion plus population without the contribution of these farmers?
1 Stars
Tonya
Columbus, United States
Indian scholars should carryout any research work just to describe the importance and significance of farming in the country's inclusive growth and in the political fields of contemporary and modern India.
1 Stars
James
Sydney, Australia
Sex, Kidney, senseless movies of Bollywood and farmers suicide - this is India.
1 Stars
Chintan
Ambala, India
Indian politicians have no time to think about farmers, they are busy in saving their seats in government, in Lok Sabha or in Indian politics. Agriculture minister Sharad Pawar has other Important works to do because He is BCCI president and going to be ICC president soon. ministers can't make crore of rupees by taking care of poor farmers.
1 Stars
Suryasnata
Chandigarh, India
It is absolute shame. We will have to pay for the height of ignorance.
1 Stars
Shweta
Shimla, India
Every political leaders love to talk about poor and need of the policies for the welfare of the people living at the bottom line in society. In practice, they work for the welfare of their own people. who cares of farmers jumping infront of running trains setting themselves fire or consuming poison.
1 Stars
Syed
Singapore, Singapore
The road to globalization should either start from remote village or to end in the remote village in the country. No concept of globalization would work without including the grwoth of villages in in it. India should understand it fast otherwise the bubble would certainly burst.
1 Stars
Jamie
Vancouver, Canada
Transform the villages as the centre of growth and cities as satellite - this is single way to have inclusive growth. You can get nothing by mere talking about economic growth.
1 Stars
Sukhbahar
Ludhiana, India
Industrialists have begun war against farmers for grabbing their lands in the name of SEZs and the government, Central and states both, are supporting them in it. Farmers have no way but to end their lives. This is shameful.
1 Stars
Shameem
Aligarh, India
Good article!! - let me give you another example of wheat import scam. The policymakers sitting in South Avenue in New Delhi is manufacturing a food crisis in a complete planned manner. The government of India has imported 1.79 million metric tonnes of wheat in past six months. The Indian farmers are getting Rs 850 per quintal as wheat price from the government while the farmers of foreign countries is getting Rs 1600 per quintal from the government of India. Now, it is up to we Indians to decide who is killing farmers..
1 Stars
Manishkumar
Kottayam, India
I am sure and very much convinced that there is a conspiracy going on against Indian agriculture. some forces are working inside and outside the country to make India, the country of one billion people, food dependent on other countries. It seems our leaders are also involved in it
1 Stars
Hiten
Ranchi, India
Children like Dharmendra are living in almost every village in Vidarbha.
1 Stars
Jocelyn
Houston, United States
1.5 lakh farmers committed suicide in India??? This is real example of mass killing. Government of India is bigger than Al qaeda it seems.
1 Stars
Elias
Bombay, India
Political parties are ignoring such an important issue to deal at their own peril. The whole nation would pay for their ignorance.
1 Stars
Iman
Tehran, Iran
AND INDIAN SAY THEY ARE ROLE MODEL FOR DEVELOPING COUNTRIES.
1 Stars
Puneet
Noida, India
Government is still discussing to create a National Disaster Assistance Fund to help farmers at the time of crop failure or natural disasters like floods, drought and earthquake.
1 Stars
Swati
Amritsar, India
Great news for we people!!! The suicide mortality rate, suicide death for 100,000 persons, for male farmers have gone up from 12.3% in 1996 to 19.2% in 2004. Isn't it great growth rate we achieved?
1 Stars
Lalit
Kanpur, India
Thanx Shameen for making us aware about wheat import scam.
1 Stars
Corey
Birmingham, United Kingdom
Hey James! You forgot to add IT, Call centers, child labour, poverty and corruption in the list. :-)
1 Stars
Michael
Jakarta, Indonesia
Number is horrible. How can India afford suicide at such huge scale?
1 Stars
Martin
Liverpool, United Kingdom
Indian farmers and tigers are at the danger to be disappeared soon. Indian government is much worried about the numbers of big cats than farmers.
1 Stars
Sonu
Thiruvananthapuram, India
UPA government is interested in making India dependent on other countries for food items. It is visible now.
1 Stars
Shameem
Aligarh, India
This is the right time to implement Gandhian policy for the development of Indian villages. Gandhi wanted to make villages as centre of growth but it never happened because of socialist character of Indian government just after the independence. Gandhian way is the best way to transform villages across the country and strong will power is the pre-requisite of the implementation.
1 Stars
Syed
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
"Save your farmers if you want to save your country".
1 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
the indian farmer is a very sorry figure. it never gets fair price for its produce, neither does any support in terms of credits from the government or financial exploitation. as a result, they have to take money from pawn brokers and local money lenders at exceptionally high interest rates. ultimately, they are left with nothing but mountain sized loans to be paid off. if their seasonal yield is not good enough or below expectation, then there is no way out of this trap. then the generally depressed farmer considers suicide to be a viable option to end his never ending misery.

the blame squarely lies on the government that has not being able to provide enough support price for the indian farmer's produce, lacks a good and just credit policy for farmers, must make arrangements for crop insurance at low premiums etc., etc. else, all the development that we show for will mean nothing, nothing at all.
1 Stars
Jonty instablogs.com
New Delhi, India
@ Martin:

Yes, we must be concerned about tigers as well. Without tigers, there won’t be any farmers. However, we are not prioritizing one death above the other. Those are two grave issues but separate. Please refrain from making childish comparisons.
1 Stars
Salil
Kochi, India
JAI JAWAN, JAI KISAN!!!!!!!!!!! INDIA MUST DO SOMETHING ABOUT FARMERS KILLING THEMSELVES. THEY FEED US BUT REMAIN EMPTY STOMACH!!! SHAME ON YOU POLITICIANS!!!!!!!!!
1 Stars
Julie
New Delhi, India
@ Jonty I think you have completely missed the comments written above on tigers' killing. It is not the question of prioritizing one death above the other but focusing and discussing one (TIGERS) death over other (FARMERS). Can you imagine how huge the number is - 1.5 Lakh farmers committed suicide in eight years. AND I didn't get your statement - "Without tigers, there won’t be any farmers." If you could make it clear I will be much thankful to you.
1 Stars
Pang
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Politicians are important than farmers in India. God save Indian farmers.
1 Stars
Adam
Perth, Australia
Agriculture minister is busy counting funds BCCI is earning from sponsors. How he is managing the richest cricket board and the most ill-fated agriculture ministry in the world?
1 Stars
Mariam
Lahore, Pakistan
Wheat import scam seems another entry in the list of scams done by political leaders in India.
1 Stars
Siddiqur
Dhaka, Bangladesh
26 crore Indians living below poverty line would meet the same fate one day. wait and watch.